User talk:Hiccup/Newer Super Mario Bros. Wii

Should...?
Should these Newer Super Mario Bros. Wii articles be deleted? It seems that they're in the userspace just to dodge rules. --AttackedbyGlitch 16:20, 26 July 2013 (EDT)
 * No. It's Hiccup's game. Dont delete it, it is fine the way it is.
 * Actually no, it isn't. Allow me to quote the User Subpage rules. Ahem.
 * "Please note that user space is not meant to be a sub-wiki for content that falls outside of TCRF's scope, such as fan-made games or hacks. Please only create sub-pages that meet our guidelines, and that you fully intend to move to the main space at some point."


 * And before you bring up Sonic Robo Blast 2 and Mushroom Kingdom Fusion, those were made before the "no fanstuffs" rule was made and were simply grandfathered in.
 * I'm not trying to be a backseat moderator, but these things are taking up almost the entirety of the "Articles for deletion" category. -- QuirkyKirk 17:37, 12 October 2013 (EST)
 * For one, Hiccup (to my knowledge) wasn't involved with the game's development. The difference between this and the examples you gave, Kirk, is that this isn't a fangame but rather a very well-done and polished hack...or at least, I'm pretty sure it's a hack. -WarioBarker (talk) 17:52, 12 October 2013 (EDT)


 * Please see this Jul topic. Personally, I don't mind the article existing, but then again I have a bit of a bias... oh well.  犬夜叉 ( Inuyasha )  18:00, 12 October 2013 (EDT)


 * No, Hiccup had nothing to do with the game, and yes, it's a hack. I was the lead programmer for Newer and am... not entirely sure how I feel about it being up on TCRF. The articles were awful and full of misinformation at the beginning, though they've slowly improved over time. I like to think that it's a fairly notable hack, but of course I am biased ... -Treeki (talk) 04:18, 13 October 2013 (EDT)