User talk:FCandChill

About Your Request to Delete Subpage for Rhythm Heaven Fever

May I ask why you want to delete the English translation differences subpage for Rhythm Heaven Fever? There are many other subpages that goes in-depth on differences in English translation. Mr. Kite (talk) 18:31, 28 May 2021 (UTC)

Deleting pages for Roblox Games.

Could you please tell my why you think user made Roblox games, aren't games? ThijsDeGamer (talk) 15:26, 4 August 2024 (UTC)

It's user generated content inside a game, in a similar fashion to a Mario Maker level, therefore, it's not eligible to be on TCRF.--FCandChill (talk) 01:31, 5 August 2024 (UTC)

I first want to say that I respect that you added the delete templates. I did remove them, due to nothing happening for some time (15 days) and according to the rules it is possible for these games to be allowed with the approval of a moderator. Which I assumed happend, possibly in private, due to the Robot 64 page being up for over 3 months now. The rest of this is kinda a rant so you can ignore it (unless you want to know my opinion lol). Roblox isn't a game though, it's considered a platform. Roblox functions like a social media platform mixed in with a game engine. Roblox is just as much as a platform as Unity Web Player, which is considered a platform according to this page. This is because without Roblox, you cannot play games made for the platform, the same thing counts for the Unity Web Player. Games are created for these platforms and cannot directly be played without using the platform (emulation does exist, but this argument gets countered by the existance of wii games.). You can also recreate the services given by Roblox by for example using a combination of "Unity/Unreal Engine" and "Steam" or "Unreal Engine" and the "Epic Games store" (Unreal Engine and the Epic Games store are both made by the same company). I talked a bit about this in the TCRF Discord with Hawk, but he stopped responding after some time. I don't really understand why a Roblox game (not robot 64, but one brought up in a different discussion called Sonic Speed Simulator) that is backed by SEGA and developed by a game studio (gamefam), why it doesn't count as a game under the TCRF rules. It's weird to me that the rules say that every single Roblox game that is not made by the company directly falls under the category of "fan games" and that the same doesn't apply to literally any other game engine / gaming platform. I do support the decision of banning Scratch games, as scratch games tend to be made by kids having a go with a game engine for the first time. Making a game quality standerd could possibly fix this issue. I don't think that making these games need to be approved by mods first is a bad idea (or having another system in place like needing a certain "visit" count.). The problem with this is that they tend to reject every Roblox game. (Like Sonic Speed Simulator or event games that are backed by multi- million / billion dollar corporations.) ThijsDeGamer (talk) 23:24, 6 August 2024 (UTC)

FCandChill, did you actually ask the staff before doing that...? I find that to be a little rude to just call to delete pages that actually have content on them on the dubious domineering basis that "they're user generated content". Games that use a engine aren't exactly "user generated content"... Chimes (talk) 06:20, 7 August 2024 (UTC)

User Generated content or Asset IDs are abbreviated to as UGC in most Asset IDs related to games. Some asset IDs were copylocked, patched or uncopylocked depending on a save instance command that forces the asset ID to be saved from a studio project and creates a .rbxl file in it. There are warnings and bans for asset IDs and could have been a thing. Croper-1 (talk) 08:51, 9 August 2024 (UTC)

none of the administration team actually approved the page being created again, and it was deleted last year for the exact same reasons it's been deleted again now. the only reason it was up for as long as it was was because even though we were aware of the page being created again, despite specifically saying it wasn't allowed, no one actually got around to taking action against it before now. either way, the policy for games within games like this one is not one that will be changed, and I'd appreciate it if people stopped going behind the administration's back to just do whatever they want HugetteHikari (talk) 20:40, 11 September 2024 (UTC)

My theory, is that, FCandChill said it's User Generated Content (Such as Asset IDS, like Places, Clothes, and others) so they are not games, they are places. The Robot 64 experience is a fangame based on Super Mario 64 for the N64, but it's a place on Roblox only. So asset IDS are very much like Scratch Project IDS that's why. I was correct because, there is an app called Roblox Studio, which is also similar to SMM (Mario Maker), and there is a banning system for experiences, chat logs, but ran by AI, and it's worse. The subpage for the V3 article, says it's UNCOPYLOCKED, which indicates that a copy of a saved instance, was grabbed from the files.

So games inside Roblox are not games. They are places or experiences like real world experiences, and these default places varies more on exploration.

So User:Techorante was responsible for creating this Robot 64 page.

DISCUSSION CLOSED.

Croper-1 (talk) 16:05, 22 October 2024 (UTC)